Environmental & social issues overwhelmingly ignored by proxy voters, Planet Tracker finds

Despite 80% increase in proposals submitted in annual shareholder meetings over last decade, environmental & social factors comprise only 7%

LONDON, 10th May 2022: With the US proxy season well under way, latest research by financial think tank Planet Tracker indicates that critical ESG issues, such as plastic pollution and declining biodiversity, rarely make it on to the agenda – posing a fundamental concern for the investors represented by institutional investment giants, such as BlackRock and Vanguard.

In an analysis of proposals submitted and votes cast from 2012-2021, Planet Tracker found that, despite a rising trend in ESG proposals over the last decade, the vast majority were for governance-related topics, and many of these to ensure compliance – such as approving minutes and auditors.. Social and environmental factors, meanwhile, comprised only 5% and 2% of these proposals respectively.

Perhaps most disturbingly, many important issues never or rarely make the annual shareholder meetings: over the last five years, for example, plastic issues have been raised only eight times and the word ‘biodiversity’ has only once made the agenda.

What’s more, investment giants, including State Street, UBS, Vanguard and BlackRock, hold a significant number of votes at these proxy meetings due to the size of the funds under their management, giving them considerable sway over the approval of proposals. While their public statements make them appear committed to responsible ownership and stewardship, these top asset managers often struggle to present a unified approach, voting very differently by region.

John Willis, Director of Research at Planet Tracker, comments: “Planet Tracker welcomes the growing importance of ESG proposals at shareholder meetings. However, the ESG headline figures for these annual meetings over the past decade can deceive. Hopefully, this year we will witness a new momentum on an assortment of ESG issues, not least on environmental topics where many CEOs have made public statements on net zero targets.
“But we note the scarcity of proposals on a number of important global issues. If the investment giants are unprepared to engage with corporates on these topics, they should promptly introduce direct voting for the many investors they represent”.


– ENDS –


Planet Tracker is an award-winning non-profit financial think tank aligning capital markets with planetary boundaries. Created with the vision of a financial system that is fully aligned with a net zero, resilient, nature positive and just economy well before 2050, Planet Tracker generates breakthrough analytics that reveal both the role of capital markets in the degradation of our ecosystem and show the opportunities of transitioning to a zero-carbon, nature positive economy.

Media contact

Ophelia Jeffrey
Aspectus Group

+44 (0) 7584 657 646

Related Posts

Sleeve labelling provides a short-term solution to boost recycling rates, Planet Tracker says

Currently less than nine per cent of plastic waste is recycled and attention is too often focused on the container’s material to the neglect of the type of label used. However, the availability of recycled plastics is not currently able to meet this rising demand. Consumer brands should adopt a self-help approach which ensures that labels are of the same material as the container.

Textiles industry neglecting E and S of ESG, new research finds

Textile industry shareholder meetings need increased focus on Environmental proposals. Of the 1,198 ESG proposals submitted to the annual shareholder meetings of retailers in the Planet Tracker universe since 2015, only 2% were environmental proposals. Key industry issues, such as fibre mix are not raised in shareholder meetings.

About Us

Planet Tracker is a non-profit financial think tank aligning capital markets with planetary boundaries. It was created in 2018 to investigate the risk of market failure related to environmental limits, focusing on oceans, food & land use and materials such as textiles and plastics.

Let’s Socialize

Popular Post